Both Android Auto and CarPlay have tremendously improved the in-car infotainment expertise for drivers. The two apps provide a extra revolutionary and linked strategy than most conventional techniques, mixed with a well-recognized and intuitive person interface linked to the person’s knowledge. No matter what automobile they’re in, drivers take pleasure in the identical interface and do not need to set their preferences from scratch, which renters respect essentially the most. This being mentioned, I’ve been fairly vocal about not liking every little thing about Android Auto, however is CarPlay any higher? Let’s see which is essentially the most handy when sitting behind the steering wheel.
Voice Assistant
While driving, utilizing a voice assistant might be the simplest strategy to work together with a automobile or a telephone. Both CarPlay and Android Auto assist this function, because of Siri and Google Assistant. The latter is normally praised for higher understanding requests and helps a extra complete vary of third-party companies. This permits you to management units or verify your checking account’s stability whereas sitting comfortably behind your steering wheel, whereas iPhone customers may wrestle to take action.
Left: CarPlay’s interface allows you to change or ship a message however does not show the message itself
Right: Android Auto’s interface is much less intrusive and reveals a preview of the message on prime of the app you are utilizing
In-car interactions are additionally much less irritating because of Assistant’s potential to transcribe what you are saying on the display screen, which is especially helpful when sending a message, because it allows you to discover typos rather more simply. Some may argue that is unsafe whereas driving, however have in mind the transcription is barely displayed for just a few seconds earlier than disappearing, forcing the motive force to place their focus again on the highway.
Winner: Android Auto
User Interface
Even although Android Auto is about to get an up to date appear and feel, its present interface solely reveals a single app on the automobile’s display screen, with no choice to multitask. CarPlay, however, has supplied a dashboard UI since iOS 13, which consolidates music, maps, and Siri ideas right into a single display screen. This makes it simpler to entry every little thing you want at a look, with out switching from one app to the opposite.
Left: CarPlay’s dashboard, which reveals numerous apps on a single display screen
Right: Android Auto solely reveals one app, with a dock on the backside of the display screen
Similarly, CarPlay all the time reveals shortcuts to the most recent used music, navigation, telephone, and settings apps on the left, making it simpler to leap to them whereas driving. Android Auto is not all unhealthy, although, because it does have a persistent dock on the backside of the display screen that shows the music or navigation app, with buttons to modify tracks or arrows together with your route steering.
When it involves getting into textual content, CarPlay does not require you to shift into park or placed on the parking brake to enter a vacation spot utilizing the on-screen keyboard, not like Android Auto.
Lastly, Android Auto may be very annoying in relation to handing the telephone to the passenger whereas driving, because the latter will not be capable to use Google Maps. This makes it rather more annoying to ask somebody within the automobile so as to add a cease to the itinerary utilizing the telephone, whereas it really works completely utilizing CarPlay.
Winner: CarPlay
Navigation
When utilizing Google Maps or Waze, Android Auto allows you to pan and discover the remainder of the itinerary identical to you’d in your telephone. Things aren’t so intuitive with CarPlay, as it’s a must to use arrow keys to maneuver the map, which is each harmful and counter-intuitive when driving.
Left: You want to make use of arrows to pan the map with CarPlay
Right: You can swipe on the display screen to discover the map with Android Auto
Similarly, whereas taking another route is as simple as tapping the one highlighted in gray on Android Auto, doing this does completely nothing on CarPlay. Instead, it’s a must to return to the route choices, hoping to faucet the one which corresponds to the route you noticed on the map.
Android Auto has the higher hand in comparison with CarPlay if you wish to discover the map or discover different routes when driving.
Winner: Android Auto
Third Party apps
Both platforms enable customers to put in third-party apps, equivalent to navigation, music, or podcast ones. However, the variety of apps obtainable is not fairly the identical between Android Auto and CarPlay, as the primary is appropriate with rather more apps than the second, particularly in relation to messaging. While the primary intent of driving is not to be sending out messages, it is good to know your favourite apps might be simply usable when driving.
Winner: Android Auto
Calls and Notifications
Whether you prefer it or not, you are more likely to get notifications and calls whereas driving. While each platforms are designed to deal with these safely, CarPlay is much more intrusive than Android Auto, in that banners are displayed on the backside of the display screen, which prevents you from seeing the place you are alleged to go when you want steering. On Android Auto, banners seem on the prime of the display screen. Unlike CarPlay, Android Auto allows you to dismiss a notification or mute it, which is handy when you favor to not be notified about updates despatched to a WhatsApp group however wish to maintain receiving different notifications.
Left: CarPlay does not allow you to work together with notifications
Right: Android Auto permits you to mute and dismiss notifications
When it involves “studying” a notification, Android Auto does so discreetly. CarPlay, however, takes up the entire display screen, which is kind of invasive when driving.
Worse, when receiving a name, CarPlay shows it in full display screen, which utterly hides what was beforehand displayed. On the opposite hand, Android Auto reveals a small banner on the prime of the display screen. The first platform stays on the decision web page when you decide up, whereas Android Auto merely reveals the controls within the dock.
Winner: Android Auto
Wireless
Although each CarPlay and Android Auto can work wirelessly, some producers or fashions do not assist wi-fi Android Auto, whereas they work simply effective with CarPlay. This is not essentially a giant deal, as a easy dongle could make nearly any automobile appropriate with wi-fi Android Auto, however it’s nonetheless an additional trouble.
Also, when linked wirelessly, some Android units are inclined to get extremely popular over lengthy drives, which just about by no means occurs with an iPhone. Finally, Android Auto additionally drains extra battery when used wirelessly in comparison with CarPlay.
Due to those points, CarPlay is right here, though wi-fi connectivity just isn’t Android Auto’s worst downside.
Winner: CarPlay
Screenshots
Although taking a screenshot whereas driving stays a uncommon prevalence, each CarPlay and Android Auto provide the choice to take a snippet of the display screen and share it if wanted. However, whereas the method is so simple as urgent the quantity up and facet buttons concurrently with an iPhone, it is rather more painstaking with Android Auto.
You most likely will not select an iPhone over an Android handset for taking screenshots of your automobile’s display screen, however in case you could, you higher have an Apple system.
Winner: CarPlay
Android Auto takes the win (however CarPlay is fairly superior)
Even although Android Auto appears to be the winner, you may need to gauge what issues to you when driving. Android Auto is significantly better at letting you talk whenever you’re in your automobile, each by having a far much less invasive strategy to calls and notifications but in addition by being extra clear about what you are about to ship.
CarPlay, however, has a extra trendy interface, which helps you to see a number of apps concurrently in a neat dashboard. It additionally affords a greater connection expertise, primarily when used wirelessly.
It’s additionally essential to remember Google is about to refresh Android Auto’s interface, which is able to most likely look similar to CarPlay’s, additional closing the hole with its competitor.
Read Next
About The Author
